The Avengers Are in My Magic Decks Now and I Have Complicated Feelings

Hot TakesMarvel Super HeroesCommander
Image for: The Avengers Are in My Magic Decks Now and I Have Complicated Feelings

So Marvel Super Heroes dropped on June 26, and I sat there at my kitchen table cracking a pack with Captain America staring back at me, wondering when exactly my two hobbies fused into one Hasbro-shaped object.

Earth’s Mightiest Booster Packs

Let me be clear: I am not mad. I’m a dad in his late thirties who grew up on both Magic AND comics, so on paper this is a peanut-butter-and-chocolate situation aimed directly at my wallet. The set leans on decades of comic history — Avengers, Fantastic Four, villains, the whole Galactus-looming-over-everything vibe — and it comes with four Commander precons right out of the gate. That’s the part my brain latched onto, because precons are how I actually get cards onto the table without taking out a second mortgage.

What gets me is the scale of it. Spider-Man last year felt like a toe in the water. This one feels like Wizards cannonballed into the deep end. There’s a Beginner Box built around Iron Man versus Cap, draft products, scene boxes, the works. From a business standpoint it’s smart. From a "I just wanted to play some Magic" standpoint, it’s a lot to take in.

The Part My Kids Actually Care About

Here’s the thing that softened me on the whole deal: my kids do not care about the color pie. They do not care about Standard rotation. They care that there is a Hulk card. When my oldest saw me sorting these, the first question was whether Spider-Man was in there too (different set, kiddo) and the second was whether we could play.

That’s the win for me. I spent years trying to explain Magic to people who glaze over the second I say "tap your lands," and now I’ve got a built-in hook. Is it a little cynical that the hook is one of the biggest entertainment IPs on the planet? Sure. Do I care when my seven-year-old is genuinely excited to learn? Not even a little.

Where I Land

I’ll cop to the eye-roll I did when this was first announced. Part of me misses when Magic sets were about made-up planes with made-up wizards. But I also remember being a returning player two years ago feeling totally lost, and honestly? A familiar face like Captain America is a friendlier on-ramp than "here’s a planeswalker you’ve never heard of."

From what I’ve seen at my LGS, the room is split right down the middle on this stuff — and that’s fine. You can think it’s too much crossover AND still have a blast playing it. I’m choosing to crack packs with my kids and not overthink it. Could be wrong, but that feels like the most dad way to handle it.

Join the conversation

Your email address will not be published.